Depends what you mean by "the one that got away," but there are a couple of songs that kind of remind me of Jane. Nothing's gonna stop us now by Starship was, for reasons I can't remember, "our song." And Bryan Adams' Everything I do (I do it for you) reminds me of her simply because one of the first times we were together involved half-watching Robin Hood - Prince of Thieves on the telly.
Fortunately neither song has any reason yet to start reminding me of Sarah. That would be just confusing.